Film & animatie

Is Snape Still Alive? [Harry Potter Theory]

Go to bspk.me/2XlpYmT and enter the code: 'SUPER' at checkout and get 20% off your first monthly box!
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to try and figure out if everyones favorite potions master: Severus Snape is somehow actually still alive after the events of Deathly Hallows.
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ nlcameras.info
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
J's V L O G➜ nlcameras.info
T W I T T E R➜ jonkerlin & SCB_Ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ jonkerlin & scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
nlcameras.info/plus/owgKeMGXKY038qwuf3yYlw.html
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
nlcameras.info/plus/klakDJIwefWm-s0LwiGrBw.html?view_as=subscriber

Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Reacties 

  1. SuperCarlinBrothers

    SuperCarlinBrothers

    6 dagen geleden

    Set your reminders! Join us Friday, Nov. 20 @ 6pm Eastern for an All Fandoms TRIVIA LIVE STREAM and the unveiling of our 2020 Animal Mugs!

    • Kyuubi

      Kyuubi

      3 dagen geleden

      ironically Snapes actor disappeared without wanting to be seen in his last moments the way he was...

    • Lisa Griffiths

      Lisa Griffiths

      3 dagen geleden

      Hey, I figured out the spell used on Hermonie during the battle of the department of mysteries. It's the Antonin Dolov's Curse which makes purple flames appear, I got it from the unofficial ultimate Harry Potter spellbook

    • Celina Thommesen-Kähler

      Celina Thommesen-Kähler

      4 dagen geleden

      Could you do it at 3-4 pm next time? Even Vikings need their sleep...

    • calista Potter

      calista Potter

      5 dagen geleden

      Can you do stranger things content??

    • Vasilij Milić

      Vasilij Milić

      5 dagen geleden

      Is he alive in cursed child?

  2. Eli Wolicki

    Eli Wolicki

    Minuut geleden

    You should be a little bit more careful with your words you mentioned Snape knew the attack was eminent when you should have said imminent. They mean very different things

  3. monica bang

    monica bang

    41 minuut geleden

    I agree with your assessment that Snape was smart enough to carry an antidote to the venom, and likely even had some on him. However, I think if he intended to use it he would've done so immediately, especially if Harry hadn't been there to get the information he needed. But since he was, and he'd accomplished what he set out to do, I think that ultimately when Snape looked death in the eye (much like Dumbledore did and Harry was about to do) he greeted it like an old friend.

  4. Carmen Mercedes

    Carmen Mercedes

    Uur geleden

    "tweets are not canon" HEAR THAT LAUREN FAUST?!?!? YOU CAN'T TWEET STUFF INTO CANON!!!!! (She started MLP:FiM, A.K.A. My little pony g4)

  5. Brady David

    Brady David

    Uur geleden

    the fact that they don’t say the author’s name... respect. SCB says trans rights!

  6. Debra S Barkle

    Debra S Barkle

    2 uur geleden

    Right, he lived because he had secretly married his former student who was obsessed with him since her first day of class. She was always late for class even though it was her 1st class every morning and he would stand in front of her table where she was sitting and look down at her and say, "Late again, Miss Kohler? What am I going to do with you?" Year after year this happened from the time she began school at Hogwarts until she graduated. They grew closer as friends over the years but were madly in love with each other. Snape being a real gentleman never touched her until she was older, you know, of age. And they married and had children but kept this all hidden. When he never let anyone know he was still alive, he took his family and moved to Scarborough. And we are still married to this day. As is A.R. and I can't tell you any more. 🤭

  7. claire angles

    claire angles

    3 uur geleden

    Wow just wow

  8. Big Boi Mackenzie

    Big Boi Mackenzie

    5 uur geleden

    Beard strong

  9. Dmitry Sofronov

    Dmitry Sofronov

    6 uur geleden

    I would like to think of this theory as something that makes Snape even more heroic. He could have had the antidote, but he felt like if my job's done I'm free to go. That makes it even more tragic.

  10. Jonna Heijke

    Jonna Heijke

    6 uur geleden

    They are gonna publish alan rickmans diaries!!!!

  11. Shannon Kelly

    Shannon Kelly

    7 uur geleden

    bens beard just shocked me. i haven’t watched for a few weeks and i was not prepared 😂

  12. thismomentinmylife

    thismomentinmylife

    7 uur geleden

    I was sure when you said there were two scenes where Snape was missing one of them would be that his portrait wasn't mentioned to be hanging in the headmaster's office after his death!

  13. Jeremy Anacker

    Jeremy Anacker

    12 uur geleden

    Ben shave your beard

  14. TheBrothergreen

    TheBrothergreen

    12 uur geleden

    Wait, Snape's parents were abusive? Is that pottermore lore? or did I miss something? I find it rather interesting that when harry forced snape to relive his childhood trauma, his subconscious went with OWL day at Hogwarts and not that scene from "The Cell" where the dad caught the kid playing with a barbie doll.

  15. Mitsurugi Chiba

    Mitsurugi Chiba

    13 uur geleden

    I would indeed be okay with Snape’s survival. One time when I was reading the books, I decided to make a list of all the good guys that died starting with Cedric Diggory and I included Snape in that list.

  16. Sumayya Wright

    Sumayya Wright

    14 uur geleden

    Hey Ben your hair looks like Jay! Hmm...I guess they really are starting to merge🤔😜

  17. Patrick Hamos

    Patrick Hamos

    14 uur geleden

    Yes..... He is the Half Blood Prince.

  18. Brandon Zhao

    Brandon Zhao

    15 uur geleden

    My personal question: why doesn't Nagini become master of the Elder Wand?

  19. joelieastell

    joelieastell

    16 uur geleden

    Okay, I clicked thinking this would be a bit of a throwaway mindless watch but you convinced me by the end. I don’t think Snape is alive but I do like thinking that he’s out there living a transcendent life. Thanks!

  20. kjw2

    kjw2

    18 uur geleden

    I was just wondering why couldn't Harry's parents made each other the others secret keeper? Like Lilly becomes James secret keeper and vise versa. Is there something I'm missing?

  21. Hayden Weaver

    Hayden Weaver

    23 uur geleden

    I swear, they got this idea from the Harry Potter HISHE

  22. DJ A.M.

    DJ A.M.

    Dag geleden

    I'm not even gonna try to entertain you because in the movie (Ik the books are different) & books, Nagini continually bit Snape then (in the movies) Naginini ate Snape so if they make a new Harry Potter with Nagini, they're gonna have to go back to then & explain how Nagini didn't eat Snape & how Snape didnt die

  23. Tuukka Gronholm

    Tuukka Gronholm

    Dag geleden

    No way he said before watching the video. After watching the video : weeeeeelll maybe.

  24. morning morality

    morning morality

    Dag geleden

    Honey badger just takes what it wants

  25. morning morality

    morning morality

    Dag geleden

    Harry, proffessor snape your alive. Snape, of course in alive you twit Harry, but how you dies right in front of us. Snape, magic duh im a potions master and a double agent obviously i had a back up plan. I been drinking honey badger anti venom ever since i started hanging around that ridiculous snake.

  26. Suzanne S

    Suzanne S

    Dag geleden

    All good points but remember Voldepants slashes Snape’s throat or neck first before he sics Nagini on him. Could have weakened him further,

  27. 2 Minutes of Common Sense -

    2 Minutes of Common Sense -

    Dag geleden

    Plausible Quite plausible

  28. Uzi Hill

    Uzi Hill

    Dag geleden

    ... He remained loyal to Dumbledore, so who's to say that Fawkes didn't come and phoenix-tear heal him?

    • Uzi Hill

      Uzi Hill

      Dag geleden

      Also, in his first class he says he can put "a stopper in death"

  29. Jacob Willings

    Jacob Willings

    Dag geleden

    Even if Snape was the master of the elder wand Nagini killing him would not make Voldy the master.

  30. stecky87

    stecky87

    Dag geleden

    I hope that this is true because, after all he suffered, after all he gave up to be a double agent, I hope he has some part of his life that's peaceful

  31. Connie Richards

    Connie Richards

    Dag geleden

    "Snape is simultaneously two things. One: ..." Me absolutely in sync with Ben: "THE POTIONS MASTER!"

  32. Thenorwegianguy

    Thenorwegianguy

    Dag geleden

    Why didn't Quirrell (Voldemort on his head) open the chamber of secrets in the philosopher's stone? It would be a nice distraction while he was looking for the stone.

  33. Samara Guthrie

    Samara Guthrie

    Dag geleden

    if nagini killed snape, wouldn't nagini be the true master of the elder wand, because she was human at one point

    • Samara Guthrie

      Samara Guthrie

      Dag geleden

      nevermind, forgot she was a horcrux

  34. Tuesday Ava

    Tuesday Ava

    Dag geleden

    I like the fact that she is the author, its like the equivalent of saying he who must not be named

  35. Ana Carolina Tramontini

    Ana Carolina Tramontini

    Dag geleden

    I love your channel, but if she tweets that he is dead is because he is. Next theory then 😘

  36. Philip Morin

    Philip Morin

    Dag geleden

    Can we get an animated show of Harry Potter where it goes in depth between the summers and what the order was doing in that time. Not just the Order but also the teachers and school. Canon of course.

  37. Emily Lewis

    Emily Lewis

    Dag geleden

    I love the theory! And it all checks out, I still don’t know how I feel about snape so I don’t know if he deserves the redemption?? The throw in line you have Neville however, broke my heart and I’d almost like to see that one play out, showing that Harry cared enough to send someone. Love the video guys!!

  38. Sriol

    Sriol

    Dag geleden

    On a related note: if Nagini could pass the ownership of the elder wand to Voldemort due to her being a Voldy-horcrux, surely that would mean Harry would also give Voldy ownership of the wand due to him being a horcrux too?

  39. Ironbanner 12

    Ironbanner 12

    Dag geleden

    But....but his throat was slit by Voldemort?!?!

  40. Kobster 15

    Kobster 15

    Dag geleden

    In the movie, Voldemort slits Snape’s throat, and then Nagini attacked

  41. Athe

    Athe

    Dag geleden

    I believe he took an anti venom and replenish potion every time he is near Voldemort and negini. He is a potions master after all. The potion slowly revived him and he was able to walk away after giving Harry the last clue he needed to defeat Voldemort. He then hide his identity to live a safe quiet life just in case Voldemort followers want to get revenge. Better to think he Is dead so he can live peacefully.

  42. Amy Foy

    Amy Foy

    Dag geleden

    *from Wall-E

  43. Amy Foy

    Amy Foy

    Dag geleden

    I once saw a theory that the tree from ant island is the tree form Wall-E

  44. Half-Blood Princess

    Half-Blood Princess

    Dag geleden

    Snape HAS to still be alive! After the Battle of Hogwarts, even the bodies of the Death Eaters who died were lain out in the Hall, yet Snape wasn’t? Yeah, because there was no body, because he’s still alive! I refuse to believe he’s dead.

  45. Lindsay Collins

    Lindsay Collins

    Dag geleden

    I"ve seen every single one of your Harry Potter and pixar/disney videos and I have nothing else to watch until you post again because I'm not a marvel person

  46. valleyheroine

    valleyheroine

    Dag geleden

    HISI made a video of snape surviving. It's pretty funny

  47. David Thorpe

    David Thorpe

    Dag geleden

    So picture it, Harry goes to Italy and sits down at a cafe table and orders a drink. He looks across and sees Snape, possibly with a family. They share a knowing glance at each other before he leaves and Harry knows that Snape turns out alright.

  48. Moses Sing

    Moses Sing

    Dag geleden

    Dona y ayuda a los afectado por la tormenta ETA y IOTA en Honduras. Un dolar ayuda, y mucho: gf.me/u/y9y9w2 Donate and help those affected by the tropical storm ETA and IOTA in Honduras. A dollar goes a long way: gf.me/u/y9y9w2

  49. jay hed

    jay hed

    Dag geleden

    Didn’t he get trapped in the Soul Stone????

  50. //

    //

    Dag geleden

    The question is not if snape could survive, he konws enough and has got the brains. The question is what for? He has no reason to live, because 1. Lilli is dead 2. Lillis son is about to be dead and he cannot protect him 3. Dumbledores last order was done 4. The battle of hogwarts is about to be won (snape should understand, what harry going to voldy means) 5. He shows harry the memory, that makes clear, he is no death eater, but only because he needed harry to belive him to save the world. He would nevet give this information away, because it is kind of his worst memory 6.While he could just go to azcaban and shield his mind fron the dementors easily, he would really get bored Thereby, if he just decides to die, he might be remembered as a hero without humiliation, he also will finally return to lilly. (If snape used the deluminator, would he apparate into a vulcano?(then he dies and gets to his hearts desire) :D )

  51. Jesús Urzúa

    Jesús Urzúa

    Dag geleden

    Except that in CC it is stipulated he actually died. Y stay hidden after the BH?

  52. Levi Deaton

    Levi Deaton

    2 dagen geleden

    Unbridge left her mark on Harry as well. And Voldemort

  53. Ingrid Willett

    Ingrid Willett

    2 dagen geleden

    yes

  54. Chef Paul

    Chef Paul

    2 dagen geleden

    If Alan Rickman reprised his role as Snape I would be very surprised

    • Chef Paul

      Chef Paul

      9 uur geleden

      @Patrick McGregor Duh

    • Patrick McGregor

      Patrick McGregor

      14 uur geleden

      That would be a bit hard to do since Alan Rickman is kinda dead

  55. ACLotRFan

    ACLotRFan

    2 dagen geleden

    I'm not sure that Snape would want this 'peaceful' life. I don't belive his mind found that kind of peace. I'm not saying he necessarily wanted to die, but he was smart enough to know that with his death, no one alive would know about Dumbledor's plan with the Elder Wand. And maybe by dying while serving the 'good' side once again, he would find redemption for not saving Lily.

  56. Vincent Jansen

    Vincent Jansen

    2 dagen geleden

    How come the essence of Dittany healed Harry’s snake bites after the attack in batilda’s house by Nagini? They had such a hard time healing Arthur’s wounds at saint mongo’s.

  57. R Marie

    R Marie

    2 dagen geleden

    Tweets are not CANON Me:Did I hear that correctly?

  58. Charles Dubois

    Charles Dubois

    2 dagen geleden

    the stone is the biggest clue , i would add one argument to your compilation : slughorn once said : we potion master allways keep bootles for such occation , ( desecrate the corps of beautyful aragog ) . fast foward , hermony has to find a bottle in her own bag to take his tears . ( take them) mens dont look in my pockets......

  59. Kaeryn Bass

    Kaeryn Bass

    2 dagen geleden

    The stress of years of living a double life and the death of his always love by voldemort, whom he HAD TO HATE probably left him wanting to give up on life. How could he ever explain what he had been doing and who would believe it without seeing it the way Harry did.

  60. Gamble9110

    Gamble9110

    2 dagen geleden

    I whole heartedly believe that he is alive!

  61. Josie Sandbrook

    Josie Sandbrook

    2 dagen geleden

    I have never thought of this before. I love this theory. I thought you were clutching at straws when I read the title, but well done of the research SCB team. You've got my creativity ticking.

  62. Frank Bingham

    Frank Bingham

    2 dagen geleden

    I don't think that Snape is still alive because he died in the deathly hallows.

  63. Sneha Verma

    Sneha Verma

    2 dagen geleden

    Jk Rowling: snape died. Carlin brothers: NO

  64. Aubrey Brackett

    Aubrey Brackett

    2 dagen geleden

    I like to think Snape is the one who created the Antidote for Arthur Weasley...too much of a convenience that Snape shows up just after the Healers find an antidote...He just could not reveal himself as the supplier of the Antidote...since the Dark Lord has spies everywhere.

  65. Trent Harmon

    Trent Harmon

    2 dagen geleden

    Why does ben look like, the same but also wearing a fake beard

  66. Kira Page

    Kira Page

    2 dagen geleden

    It’s all too vague to know for sure. Snape’s body wasn’t mentioned but neither was the absence of his body. I think it would be a pretty a big deal to people if his body was never found especially given the fact that Peter Petigru (? I can’t spell lol) was assumed dead because they found nothing of his body but a finger.

  67. Chad Meredith

    Chad Meredith

    2 dagen geleden

    I'd try putting that golden egg in the water if I were you. Also, I am 100 percent convinced that Snape is still alive.

  68. Zylops

    Zylops

    2 dagen geleden

    Snape, Snape, Severus Snape Snape, Snape, Severus Snape Snape, Snape, Severus Snape mm has a rythm to it.

  69. Gaius Wyrden

    Gaius Wyrden

    2 dagen geleden

    Yeah, no. Snape died, the book is crystall clear about that. He got a huge snake bite in the throat, there is absolutely no way he is not dead. He was redeemed and saw Lilys eyes before he died, that is at least something.

  70. Athan Eggl

    Athan Eggl

    2 dagen geleden

    I took a test on which Harry Potter character I was can I got snape

  71. Addison Waldo

    Addison Waldo

    2 dagen geleden

    You should do Percy Jackson content!!!! There is going to be a TV show on disney plus in about two years, and it's literally an amazing fandom. BUT DO NOT WATCH THE MOVIES!!!!! (At least don't watch them until you have read the entire last Olympian series, it will change the way you envision the books)

  72. Kate Lanxner

    Kate Lanxner

    2 dagen geleden

    Yes this theory sounds believable. Enjoyable video!

  73. Jack Scott

    Jack Scott

    2 dagen geleden

    There’s legit no point in making theories for Harry Potter anymore, they all just become canon because of JK, I’m surprised Snape isn’t already alive, Harrys real dad, Serious’ brother, black and secretly gay for Hagrid

  74. Maciej Wójtowicz

    Maciej Wójtowicz

    2 dagen geleden

    What if Snape wanted to die because he didn't want to live without Lilly or wanted to see her in afterlife...

  75. Aaron Pinder

    Aaron Pinder

    2 dagen geleden

    So you know how mad eyes eye can see through a horcrux... Dd invented his eye after he examined it after he took it from James dd... Powerful wizard got the 3rd hallow.... Or did he... That was my thoughts... But nooo... Sirius did... Cos he could not stand his best friend being out of sight

  76. Hanfei Cao

    Hanfei Cao

    2 dagen geleden

    I would personally be so happy if JK Rowling confirms that Snape survived.

  77. Jennifer Wright

    Jennifer Wright

    2 dagen geleden

    There is always hope. Always.

  78. Tako Iwao

    Tako Iwao

    2 dagen geleden

    honey badger antivenom🧐🧐🧐

  79. Michelle Wyatt

    Michelle Wyatt

    2 dagen geleden

    He moved no more... No less but no more... Yeah i didn't want him to be dead. PEACE

  80. Kingsley

    Kingsley

    2 dagen geleden

    I take it you guys have seen ‘How it should have ended’ HISHE 🤷‍♂️

  81. Rajas Bhide

    Rajas Bhide

    2 dagen geleden

    If you are making content of off a person's books then at least acknowledge their name or just stop making content from it if you find saying her name so annoying and hard

    • aaron johns

      aaron johns

      Dag geleden

      What she has done has damaged her reputation. I see no problem in separating the art from the artist, and continuing to uplift the art for what it is without continually drawing attention to the problematic creator. Saying the author gives me comfort, because those that really understand why they are choosing to make that distinction appreciate the careful choice of words. Because I’m not about to give up on the wizard of world that I’ve come to love, but she has repeatedly doubled down on statements and beliefs that I wholeheartedly do not agree with, and I appreciate her name not getting mentioned as often as possible.

  82. Lucas Biermann

    Lucas Biermann

    2 dagen geleden

    3:10 *Fangs. YOU'RE WELCOME

  83. John Banner

    John Banner

    2 dagen geleden

    Why do they keep moving chair positions when presenting this information in videos? Is it proven to keep viewer attention or be “hip”? I am a fan & know that several creators do it, just befuddling & seems like overly wasted effort

  84. Ether Mendoza

    Ether Mendoza

    2 dagen geleden

    I love these theory videos. However I’m 100% Snape was toast.

  85. Catfinity

    Catfinity

    2 dagen geleden

    Big brain

  86. Jaleb

    Jaleb

    2 dagen geleden

    What about his painting in the Head Master's office? Do we know if there's information about the relationship of him being dead and being remembered in a painting? Seems like this would be an important link between these cases.

  87. cutiepiezcontarria13

    cutiepiezcontarria13

    2 dagen geleden

    Clever idea! Definitely possible.

  88. Bryce Sagner

    Bryce Sagner

    2 dagen geleden

    I like to think that after Harry left him the spirit of Lily used some divine magic that we wouldn’t understand and gave him a second life.

  89. Blynde Mann

    Blynde Mann

    2 dagen geleden

    I would like to believe he survived.

  90. Bccdragon

    Bccdragon

    3 dagen geleden

    He is a force ghost

  91. Toby J Campbell

    Toby J Campbell

    3 dagen geleden

    He could be it would be pretty cool

  92. The Professor

    The Professor

    3 dagen geleden

    The guy from Star Wars sequels needs to play young snape in prequel of young Voldemort

  93. Isabelle Brown

    Isabelle Brown

    3 dagen geleden

    Ill say this is possible yet not probable

  94. Antwan Hart

    Antwan Hart

    3 dagen geleden

    I could believe him to be alive and if they didn’t have they found his body he has to be alive

  95. IDCookieGirl

    IDCookieGirl

    3 dagen geleden

    you should talk about the new mutants movie!

  96. Tamir Tsendjargal

    Tamir Tsendjargal

    3 dagen geleden

    You gotta love the beard

  97. Andreas Zimmermann

    Andreas Zimmermann

    3 dagen geleden

    Is there a Grande Theory which all(most) Theories presented by SCB connect?

  98. Ceru53

    Ceru53

    3 dagen geleden

    Personally, this ruins the whole Harry naming his kid after him. The point was that he's named after the two men who sacrificed their lives for himself and the rest of the wizarding world.

  99. Moshe Klavan

    Moshe Klavan

    3 dagen geleden

    Bro, HISHE is like 8 years ahead of you on this

  100. Gorgusan

    Gorgusan

    3 dagen geleden

    Consider me convinced. Snape would have totally anticipated the attack and taken the antidote before meeting with Voldermort. I accept this. Snape lives lol

Volgende